Login Subscribe
    • Players/Parents
    • College Coaches
  • Arizona
    Arkansas
    California
    Colorado
    Dakotas
    Florida
    Georgia
    Illinois
    Indiana
    Iowa
    Kansas
    Kentucky
    Michigan
    Minnesota
    Missouri
    National
    Nebraska
    Nevada
    New Jersey
    Ohio
    Oklahoma
    Oregon
    Texas
    Utah
    Virginia
    Washington
    Wisconsin
  • Loading...
  • No scores pages found.
    Loading...
  • Showcases
    • Exposure Tour Exposure Tour
    Tournaments
    • 2026 Tournaments 2026 Tournaments
    About Our Events
  • Prep Dig for
    • Players
    • Parents
    • Club Coaches
    • High School Coaches
    • College Coaches
    • Fans
    View All Features
    • Coverage Access Prep Dig articles year-round without ads.
    • Rankings See how players stack up across the country.
    • Player Profiles Build your own profile and join the Prep Dig database.
    • Coach Views Get notified when a college coach views your profile.
    • Profile Trends Track your Player Profile views over time.
    • Recruiting Tasks Stay on-track in the recruiting process
    • Recruiting Dashboard All your recruiting tools in a single place.
    • College Match Recommends colleges that match with your profile.
    • Coach Contacts Contact any program in the country.
    • Event Credits Save $25 on all Prep Dig showcases.
    • Recruiting Tips Become an expert on the recruiting process.
    • College Email Template Send customized emails directly to college coaches.
    • Scouts
    • How We Rank
    • Reviews
    • About Us
  • Wisconsin
  • Rankings

    • How We Rank

    • Archived Rankings

    • 2026 Rankings

    • 2027 Rankings

    • 2028 Rankings
  • Club Programs
  • Player Database
  • Scouts
  • Home
  • Coverage
      Arizona
      Arkansas
      California
      Colorado
      Dakotas
      Florida
      Georgia
      Illinois
      Indiana
      Iowa
      Kansas
      Kentucky
      Michigan
      Minnesota
      Missouri
      National
      Nebraska
      Nevada
      New Jersey
      Ohio
      Oklahoma
      Oregon
      Texas
      Utah
      Virginia
      Washington
      Wisconsin
  • Events
      Showcases
      • Exposure Tour Exposure Tour
      Tournaments
      • 2026 Tournaments 2026 Tournaments
      About Our Events
  • Rankings
      Loading...
  • Scores
      No scores pages found.
      Loading...
  • Features
      Prep Dig for
      • Players
      • Parents
      • Club Coaches
      • High School Coaches
      • College Coaches
      • Fans
      View All Features
      • Coverage Access Prep Dig articles year-round without ads.
      • Rankings See how players stack up across the country.
      • Player Profiles Build your own profile and join the Prep Dig database.
      • Coach Views Get notified when a college coach views your profile.
      • Profile Trends Track your Player Profile views over time.
      • Recruiting Tasks Stay on-track in the recruiting process
      • Recruiting Dashboard All your recruiting tools in a single place.
      • College Match Recommends colleges that match with your profile.
      • Coach Contacts Contact any program in the country.
      • Event Credits Save $25 on all Prep Dig showcases.
      • Recruiting Tips Become an expert on the recruiting process.
      • College Email Template Send customized emails directly to college coaches.
  • About Us
      • Scouts
      • How We Rank
      • Reviews
      • About Us
  • Support
Login Subscribe
Facebook
X
​
Natalie
Nickolai RS/MB
Class
2026
Height
5'11"
HS
Sheboygan Falls
|
WI
Nickolai is a pin attacker who preps at Sheboygan Falls where she has been a key varsity her...
Evaluation by Chris Fitzgerald
Concordia (WI)
Read more at PrepDig.com
Prep Dig
Natalie Nickolai

Natalie Nickolai | Sheboygan Falls

Natalie Nickolai

Class
2026
Position
RS/MB
Height
5'11"
School
Sheboygan Falls
Club Team
Spiketown USA
State
Position
Unlock Rankings
Concordia (WI)
  • Overview
  • Player Bio
  • Verify Player
  • Evaluation
  • News
  • Recruiting
  • Highlights
  • Gallery

About Natalie

How would you briefly describe your gameplay style?

Strong Blocker on the Rightside or middle. I find ways to score, with a variety of shots. I can hit from anyplace on the court. Strong net play. Often play all 6 rotations and am very steady passer

Can you provide a brief description of your mentality or personality?

A quiet lead by example player. I never get too high or too low on the court. A steady mindset at all times in complete control of my emotions.

What skills or qualities have you developed, such as leadership, teamwork, or community service?

I have been running our summer league team. Setting line ups and making sure players know when we play.

What type of college are you looking for?

A winning program that has a team with a strong bond. A place I can contribute to conference championships and more.

Player Claimed

This player is currently claimed. If you think this is an error, please contact us.

Expert Analysis
​
Natalie
Nickolai RS/MB
Class
2026
Height
5'11"
HS
Sheboygan Falls
|
WI
Natalie Nickolai
Nickolai is a pin attacker who preps at Sheboygan Falls where she has been a key varsity her...
Written by Chris Fitzgerald
Concordia (WI)
Read more at PrepDig.com
Prep Dig

Chris Fitzgerald | Prep Dig Scout

Chris Fitzgerald

Chris Fitzgerald

Prep Dig Lead Scout

@prepdigchris chris@prepdig.com

Nickolai is a pin attacker who preps at Sheboygan Falls where she has been a key varsity her entire career.  This past season she racked up nearly 200 kills for the Falcons where they went on to have a 24-15 season, finishing 6-1 in their conference.  She will be part of the Spiketown 17.1 squad who will be dialed up with power and balance this 2025 season.  

Written 9 months ago

Access all of Prep Dig

Subscribe to read about this player

Read Evaluation
Already a subscriber? Log in

News

10 Teams To Watch At The Prep Dig Sizzle

10 Teams To Watch At The Prep Dig Sizzle

Chris Fitzgerald • July 11, 2025

Bound To Breakout Athletes at Prep Dig Resolution

Bound To Breakout Athletes at Prep Dig Resolution

Chris Fitzgerald • January 2, 2025

Updated 2026 Wisconsin Rankings

Updated 2026 Wisconsin Rankings

Prep Dig Staff • April 27, 2023

'26 Athletes Who Dominated Top 250 Expo: Part 2

'26 Athletes Who Dominated Top 250 Expo: Part 2

Rachel Kass • November 22, 2022

All You Need To Know: Wisconsin Top 250

All You Need To Know: Wisconsin Top 250

Eric Gardner • November 18, 2022

Recruiting

  • School
  • Offer?
  • Visit
Concordia (WI) Concordia (WI)
Committed on 08/14/2025
Visited on 02/27/2025

Related Players

View other players from the same club team.

Alayna Glidden

Alayna Glidden

S
5'6" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Alyssa Koval

Alyssa Koval

OH
5'10" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Brooklyn O’Malley

Brooklyn O’Malley

MB
5'11" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Cecilia Higgins

Cecilia Higgins

DS/L
5'7" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Chayse Penzenstadler

Chayse Penzenstadler

OH
5'10" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Elaina Butz

Elaina Butz

DS/L
5'6" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Kailyn Kline

Kailyn Kline

DS/L
5'3" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Keira Lynch

Keira Lynch

MB/RS
5'11" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Rebecca Krause

Rebecca Krause

OH/RS
5'9" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Savannah Mcclure

Savannah Mcclure

MB
5'11" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Sofia Rodriguez

Sofia Rodriguez

DS/L/S
5'7" • 2026 • Wisconsin

View other players from the same high school.

Calla Gromowski

Calla Gromowski

DS/L
5'2" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Kenley Mortenson

Kenley Mortenson

S
5'7" • 2026 • Wisconsin
Abigail Beaumont

Abigail Beaumont

S
5'8" • 2027 • Wisconsin
Mykenna Weigert

Mykenna Weigert

2027 • Wisconsin
Nora Halverson

Nora Halverson

OH/RS
5'7" • 2027 • Wisconsin

Highlights

Gallery

Loading...
Home Wisconsin Player Rankings Natalie Nickolai

Want to read more about Natalie Nickolai?

Subscribe Today

Prep Network

  • Prep Network
  • Prep Dig
  • Prep Girls Hoops
  • Prep Hoops
  • Prep Lacrosse
  • Prep Redzone
  • Prep Soccer
  • Prep Softball

Company

  • News
  • About
  • Careers
  • Store
  • Partner Interest Form

Resources

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • Cookie Policy
  • NCSA College Recruiting
  • Recruiting Tips
  • Student Loan Resources
  • College Scholarship Search

Support

  • My Account
  • Contact
  • Sitemap

© 2025 Prep Dig. All rights reserved.